Difference between revisions of "Replacing hard drives"
Martin Cupak (talk | contribs) (HDDs replace/models page - initial version) |
Martin Cupak (talk | contribs) m (add numbers on 12V Amps and total Watts for drives used by DFN) |
||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
All of the drives we used so far have lower spin rate to reduce power & heat (5600RPM or so) and typically are cheaper to buy. | All of the drives we used so far have lower spin rate to reduce power & heat (5600RPM or so) and typically are cheaper to buy. | ||
| − | We use 10TB WDC WD100EFAX now in most of DFN cameras in Australia (that is older model | + | We use 10TB WDC WD100EFAX now in most of DFN cameras in Australia (that is an older 10TB model, very reliable). |
We had some issues with the 8TB model (specifically WD80EFAX), which was drawing higher spin up current and consequently some of the drives were "disappearing" during use causing data integrity problems, but the 6TB (WD60EFRX) has been perfectly OK. Often a combination of one WD80EFAX and two WD60EFRX works pretty well too. | We had some issues with the 8TB model (specifically WD80EFAX), which was drawing higher spin up current and consequently some of the drives were "disappearing" during use causing data integrity problems, but the 6TB (WD60EFRX) has been perfectly OK. Often a combination of one WD80EFAX and two WD60EFRX works pretty well too. | ||
There is now (2023-2024) a new WD Red Pro model line [https://documents.westerndigital.com/content/dam/doc-library/en_us/assets/public/western-digital/product/internal-drives/wd-red-pro-hdd/product-brief-western-digital-wd-red-pro-hdd.pdf]. However, those are spinning faster at 7200RPM. | There is now (2023-2024) a new WD Red Pro model line [https://documents.westerndigital.com/content/dam/doc-library/en_us/assets/public/western-digital/product/internal-drives/wd-red-pro-hdd/product-brief-western-digital-wd-red-pro-hdd.pdf]. However, those are spinning faster at 7200RPM. | ||
| − | These are obviously better because faster, although that is not really needed for the use in DFN camera systems. More important is the wattage - I would select a type that '''uses less power''' (in watts), same as has '''lower peak 12V current''' (in | + | These are obviously better because faster, although that is not really needed for the use in DFN camera systems. More important is the wattage - I would select a type that '''uses less power''' (in watts), same as has '''lower peak 12V current''' (in amps). |
| + | |||
| + | WD80EFAX has 12VDC peak current 1.85Amp and max power 8.8W, which causes issues with both DFNEXT and DFNSMALL camera system types. | ||
| + | WD100EFAX/WD60EFRX have 12VDC peak current 1.79Amp/1.75Amp and max power 5.7W/5.3W and both are okay. | ||
Another key parameter is recording technology - definitely select drives with '''CMR''', not '''SMR'''. | Another key parameter is recording technology - definitely select drives with '''CMR''', not '''SMR'''. | ||
| − | As of 2024, we would recommend WD Red Plus line [https://documents.westerndigital.com/content/dam/doc-library/en_us/assets/public/western-digital/product/internal-drives/wd-red-plus-hdd/product-brief-western-digital-wd-red-plus-hdd.pdf] rather than the Pro line. | + | As of 2024, we would recommend '''WD Red Plus''' line [https://documents.westerndigital.com/content/dam/doc-library/en_us/assets/public/western-digital/product/internal-drives/wd-red-plus-hdd/product-brief-western-digital-wd-red-plus-hdd.pdf] rather than the Pro line. |
| − | For example, the Swiss team now uses this model in Oman: 8TB WD Red Plus (WD80EFZZ) with 5640 RPM and 6.2 Watt, and they are happy with the drives. | + | For example, the Swiss team now uses this model in Oman: 8TB WD Red Plus (WD80EFZZ) with 5640 RPM, 1.75 Amps and 6.2 Watt, and they are happy with the drives. |
8TB/6TB models WD80EFPX/WD60EFPX use even less power, looking at the datasheet. The larger 14/12TB models WD140EFGX WD120EFBX also seem to be well power optimised, we suppose these should be OK for DFN cameras and two of these per camera system shall provide heaps of disk space compared to 3x6TB or similar as 3x8TB. | 8TB/6TB models WD80EFPX/WD60EFPX use even less power, looking at the datasheet. The larger 14/12TB models WD140EFGX WD120EFBX also seem to be well power optimised, we suppose these should be OK for DFN cameras and two of these per camera system shall provide heaps of disk space compared to 3x6TB or similar as 3x8TB. | ||
We also recommend to optimise cost per TB of capacity, it might be more economical to buy just two larger drives per camera and get more capacity than by using three smaller drives. Or one can extend the capacity at little extra cost, reducing the maintenance efforts needed to manage (eg delete) the data. | We also recommend to optimise cost per TB of capacity, it might be more economical to buy just two larger drives per camera and get more capacity than by using three smaller drives. Or one can extend the capacity at little extra cost, reducing the maintenance efforts needed to manage (eg delete) the data. | ||
Revision as of 11:19, 17 January 2024
How-to replace HDDs
Replacing magnetic hard drives is easy, as long as the drives are not powered on (eg 'python /opt/dfn-software/disable_ext-hd.py'), the camera box can stay powered ON. Just be careful when touching any wiring inside the box. Please follow HDDs replace checklist, which includes instructions regarding formatting.
Recommended HDD models (2024)
All of the drives we used so far have lower spin rate to reduce power & heat (5600RPM or so) and typically are cheaper to buy. We use 10TB WDC WD100EFAX now in most of DFN cameras in Australia (that is an older 10TB model, very reliable). We had some issues with the 8TB model (specifically WD80EFAX), which was drawing higher spin up current and consequently some of the drives were "disappearing" during use causing data integrity problems, but the 6TB (WD60EFRX) has been perfectly OK. Often a combination of one WD80EFAX and two WD60EFRX works pretty well too.
There is now (2023-2024) a new WD Red Pro model line [1]. However, those are spinning faster at 7200RPM.
These are obviously better because faster, although that is not really needed for the use in DFN camera systems. More important is the wattage - I would select a type that uses less power (in watts), same as has lower peak 12V current (in amps).
WD80EFAX has 12VDC peak current 1.85Amp and max power 8.8W, which causes issues with both DFNEXT and DFNSMALL camera system types. WD100EFAX/WD60EFRX have 12VDC peak current 1.79Amp/1.75Amp and max power 5.7W/5.3W and both are okay.
Another key parameter is recording technology - definitely select drives with CMR, not SMR.
As of 2024, we would recommend WD Red Plus line [2] rather than the Pro line.
For example, the Swiss team now uses this model in Oman: 8TB WD Red Plus (WD80EFZZ) with 5640 RPM, 1.75 Amps and 6.2 Watt, and they are happy with the drives.
8TB/6TB models WD80EFPX/WD60EFPX use even less power, looking at the datasheet. The larger 14/12TB models WD140EFGX WD120EFBX also seem to be well power optimised, we suppose these should be OK for DFN cameras and two of these per camera system shall provide heaps of disk space compared to 3x6TB or similar as 3x8TB.
We also recommend to optimise cost per TB of capacity, it might be more economical to buy just two larger drives per camera and get more capacity than by using three smaller drives. Or one can extend the capacity at little extra cost, reducing the maintenance efforts needed to manage (eg delete) the data.
